Saturday, February 25, 2023

Thoughts on the Los Padres National Forest Closure (Storm Damage January 2023)

 

Upper North Fork Matilija. Slide on the high side east bank. 

Regarding the recent closure I have been silent thus far. These days working as a USFS Volunteer with The Partners In Preservation I thought it best not to inject my personal opinion into such contentious matters. I still stand by that. Plus what's done is done, as they say no use in crying over spilt milk. While I have been able to get into the field during the closure doing official site assessments I like most all of you, don't enjoy the current situation, and look to propose future solutions. 

Refugio Road, photo credit: Curt Cragg

Here's what what we do know. The United States Forest Service is both understaffed, and underfunded. It's been this way for years. The way I understand it and correct me if I'm wrong here, is plenty of money becomes available during/after a wildfire but for natural disasters such as this that's not the case. So in such instances where residents were left stranded, cut off from food, basic essentials, medications, roads completely destroyed, trails unrecognizable, all out wide spread forest destruction. It is not inconceivable to imagine perhaps panic sets in on a department that is overwhelmed and lacking the resources they so desperately need.  All that said was this broad shutdown justified and should these continue to be something the public comes to expect? On the latter I for one hope not. We can do better. 

Mono Campground, photo credit: Los Padres Forest Association.

One thing FS doesn't lack is volunteers. Free labor, why not lean more on us in these situations? We are here, always standing by and ready for deployment. Yes they already utilize volunteers but in my opinion not enough. I am proposing each ranger district assign specific trails/roads to their volunteers who can then after a crisis immediately assess the damages and in real time report back on what should or should not be closed. You wont need a broad forest closure if you have hundreds of volunteers all ready and trained to descend upon their pre assigned locations after these types of events. Of course with that comes following proper check in and check out procedures with LP communications, and adhering to safety protocols, perhaps even requiring teams carry satellite communicator's in the field. Instead of a handful of the same people spread out over months assessing individual locations we launch a full scale volunteer assault within the first week, put eyes on the entire forest and use pinpoint precision to close what needs closing, while leaving the rest open for public enjoyment. Those not doing field surveys can help by posting signs at all the trailheads warning of possible dangers. This is obviously a over simplified explanation. A program like this will take thought and preparation so might as well get started on it, or something like it. 

Grade Valley,  photo credit: Craig Carey & T111

Imagine the pride and satisfaction both the people and the administrators can have knowing they can work together in times of crisis for the greater good of the community and the forest. Trust restored, problem solved. I don't want to hear it cant be done, because it can. You don't need money to train volunteers when you can use other volunteers to do it. I will be the first to raise my hand to help anyone that wants to participate and learn how to properly survey a trail. And I'm not alone, countless others would do the same. Do the hard stuff, prepare ahead of time. A good solution is often not an easy one. I urge the Forest Service to consider expanding the duties of its volunteers. Lean on the established trail organizations and individuals who have proven themselves in the field. We want to help, please let us do more. The Los Padres could if there was a will and under the right leadership Pioneer a world class volunteer program, that becomes the gold standard across all forests.


Hwy 33, photo credit: Caltransdistrict7

If you enjoyed this post you can use the feature below to subscribe by email and receive additional posts delivered to your inbox as I complete them. If you don't want to follow by email there is also the option to subscribe via the RSS feed reader widget. Which you can access from the desktop view.  Thanks for the support.  

Subscribe

* indicates required

13 comments:

Terra C said...

Absolutely agree!! There's no reason a multi faceted assessment can't be done, quite honestly I think it can start soon too. I understand closures, of the road itself where it's compromised. But unilateral closures of trails where it can hiked in is not right. People can hike in & determine for themselves whether it's feasible for them to continue. At any time we are always taking a risk when hiking, things can happen at any time. Volunteers definitely need to be utilized more, to have this spectacular season of water received, albeit destructive in some places, and to not be able to experience the trails is disheartening.

Lost In The Los Padres said...

Good to hear from you Terra, appreciate your support and thanks for dropping a note. See you out there soon.

Anonymous said...

Did you send this to the people In leadership positions in the FS so maybe you can get someone to Champion it?

Lost In The Los Padres said...

Not yet, but I will

F said...

I don't think the government likes solutions other than government solutions. They don't really trust volunteers as anything but labor. There may be liability issues if a volunteer makes the wrong call.

Anonymous said...

I am interested in reading this discussion and hope to add comments later. With the current weather, trail conditions and access are being impacted. - H. Anderson

Lost In The Los Padres said...

F, all we need be is labor. Provide the data and they make the calls.

Lost In The Los Padres said...

Look forward to hearing your comments H. Anderson.

wildsouthland said...

What I think the Forest Service fails to grasp is that broad-sided, long-term closures actually encourages folks to disregard them while simultaneously fostering disrespect and suspicion of the agency. As Jack Elliott has noted, 1/3rd of Santa Barbara County is Forest Service land. The Forest Service has criminalized entering upon 1/3rd of Santa Barbara County! It's patently absurd, overly heavy-handed, and quite frankly unenforceable. If the Forest Service can't even survey the forest because it's resources are so stretch, it sure as hell won't be able to enforce the closure.

Chris Cameron said...

Really good post. I enjoy reading your posts about adventures, but adventures require access. Using volunteers to review access, repair trails, and give a good assessment of what should be open and closed is a GREAT idea. I hope you share this with USFS administration.

Lost In The Los Padres said...

Thanks, Chris. I did indeed share my thoughts with a few folks in the USFS.

Victor said...

Thanks for this blog, I've come across it several times while planning out new places to explore in LPNF! Very sad to see that winter closure extended to June for Grade Valley and other higher elevation areas, especially as fire season now seems like it will regularly shut down forests now for months as well. Your idea is a great one.

Anonymous said...

Very much enjoyed your blog! So disappointed West Camino Cielo is closed between the gun club entrance and Refugio road. I imagine the signage posted that indicated a reopening June 13th was put up to placate locals that enjoy using this off-road access. After sizing up the Fortified heavy pipe fences at either end, I can see money is being put into non-access versus access to this public land. Saddened by that.